LOCATION
City, neighborhood, ZIP
  •   Shelter Island, NY
REFINE SEARCH
Set price, beds, baths, etc.

 to 


 





 to 



Sort by  
Choose an option below

 No properties for sale matched your search

Tip: Try to expand your search area or adjust some of the filters.

 No sold properties matched your search

Tip: Try to expand your search area or adjust some of the filters.
Post your rentals on Trulia and Craigslist
13 North Brander Parkway, Shelter Island NY
17 photos

JUST ADDED

by () on {PROPERTY_GENERIC_PRICE_REDUCED_DATE_TRUNCATED}

OPEN ,

3 br  /  2 ba

Single-Family Home

(11964)

Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl R…

Source: danielgale.com danielgale.com

Broker: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl R…

Agent: Susan C. Cincotta

Listing Type: Rental

Year Built: 1959

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
Picturesque Cottage In Quiet Beachy Neighborhood Close To Boating Water Access And Private Beaches With Stainless And Granite Kitchen…

$28,000 /mo
16 Sunshine Road, Shelter Island NY
12 photos

by () on {PROPERTY_GENERIC_PRICE_REDUCED_DATE_TRUNCATED}

OPEN ,

3 br  /  2½ ba

Single-Family Home

(11964)

Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl R…

Source: danielgale.com danielgale.com

Broker: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl R…

Agent: Linda McCarthy

Listing Type: Rental

Year Built: 2010

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
This Home Was Recently Built In 2010 And Offers A Wonderful Open Floorplan. Great For Entertaining With Wood Floor Throughout. Cooks…

$25,000 /mo
8 Southwick Lane, Shelter Island NY
14 photos

by () on {PROPERTY_GENERIC_PRICE_REDUCED_DATE_TRUNCATED}

OPEN ,

3 br  /  3 ba

Single-Family Home

(11964)

Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl R…

Source: danielgale.com danielgale.com

Broker: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl R…

Agent: Susan C. Cincotta

Listing Type: Rental

Year Built: 1978

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
Open, Airy With Convenient Floor Plan For Entertaining. Formal Dining And Living Rooms Have Doors To Deck Which Runs The Length Of…

$45,000 /mo
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
4 photos

by () on {PROPERTY_GENERIC_PRICE_REDUCED_DATE_TRUNCATED}

OPEN ,

4 br  /  2 ba  /  1,440 sqft

Single-Family Home

(11964)

VLSHomes.com

Source: VLSHomes.com VLSHomes.com

Broker: VLSHomes.com

Listing Type: Rental

Year Built: 1961

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
SHELTER ISLAND-Perfect summer rental located on a quiet lane. Just 100 feet to a sandy beach, or a short stroll to a lifeguarded beach,…

$40,000 /mo
 Shelter Is, Shelter Island NY
photos

by () on {PROPERTY_GENERIC_PRICE_REDUCED_DATE_TRUNCATED}

OPEN ,

4 br  /  4 ba  /  4,301 sqft

Single-Family Home

(11964)

The Corcoran Group

Source: corcoran.com corcoran.com

Broker: The Corcoran Group

Agent: Penelope Moore, SVP

Listing Type: Rental

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
ELEGANT SHELTER ISLAND HARBORFRONT WITH BOAT BASINThis stunning traditional is set on over 2 acres with over 285 feet of waterfrontage…

$7,000 /mo
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
7 photos

by () on {PROPERTY_GENERIC_PRICE_REDUCED_DATE_TRUNCATED}

OPEN ,

1 br  /  1 ba  /  350 sqft

Single-Family Home

(11964)

janalyntravismesser.com

Source: janalyntravismesser.com janalyntravismesser.com

Broker: janalyntravismesser.com

Agent: Janalyn Messer

Listing Type: Rental

Year Built: 1800

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
SHELTER ISLAND-HISTORIC WATERFRONT PROPERTY Step back in time on the 2nd oldest owned property on Shelter Island. This is the cottage…

$20,000 /mo
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
photos

by () on {PROPERTY_GENERIC_PRICE_REDUCED_DATE_TRUNCATED}

OPEN ,

3 br  /  2 ba  /  1,842 sqft

Single-Family Home

(11964)

janalyntravismesser.com

Source: janalyntravismesser.com janalyntravismesser.com

Broker: janalyntravismesser.com

Agent: Janalyn Messer

Listing Type: Rental

Year Built: 1980

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
SHELTER ISLAND-BEACH COTTAGE WITH DOCK Panoramic views, sandy beach, and dock make this a wonderful vacation house. There are 3BR,…

$10,000 /mo
6 Shorewood Road, Shelter Island NY
photos

by () on {PROPERTY_GENERIC_PRICE_REDUCED_DATE_TRUNCATED}

OPEN ,

4 br  /  2½ ba  /  2,500 sqft

Single-Family Home

(11964)

The Corcoran Group

Source: corcoran.com corcoran.com

Broker: The Corcoran Group

Agent: Bernard Mollahan

Listing Type: Rental

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
CUSTOM FARMHOUSE NEAR BEACHESIn Shorewood, 4 Bedroom, 2.5 Baths Traditional with open plan, cathedral ceiling great room with stone…

$12,000 /mo
 Shelter Is, Shelter Island NY
photos

by () on {PROPERTY_GENERIC_PRICE_REDUCED_DATE_TRUNCATED}

OPEN ,

4 br  /  3 ba  /  2,400 sqft

Single-Family Home

(11964)

The Corcoran Group

Source: corcoran.com corcoran.com

Broker: The Corcoran Group

Agent: Gina Surerus, SVP

Listing Type: Rental

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
SILVER BEACH GEMThis immaculate, airy 4 bedroom home sits across from the access to Silver Beach and Shell Beach and kayak & boating…

$20,000 /mo
4 Bayshore Drive, Shelter Island NY
18 photos

by () on {PROPERTY_GENERIC_PRICE_REDUCED_DATE_TRUNCATED}

OPEN ,

3 br  /  2 ba

Single-Family Home

(11964)

Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl R…

Source: danielgale.com danielgale.com

Broker: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl R…

Agent: Susan C. Cincotta

Listing Type: Rental

Year Built: 1973

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
Across From Access To West Neck Bay On Large Lot Next To Association Property And Field. This Waterview Classic Modern Has A Fabulous…

$40,000 /mo
100 South Midway Road, Shelter Island NY
20 photos

by () on {PROPERTY_GENERIC_PRICE_REDUCED_DATE_TRUNCATED}

OPEN ,

4 br  /  3 ba

Single-Family Home

(11964)

Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl R…

Source: danielgale.com danielgale.com

Broker: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl R…

Agent: Linda McCarthy

Listing Type: Rental

Year Built: 1986

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
Beachy And Beautiful! Stroll To Wades Beach From This 4Br/3Ba Ideal Summer Home W/Heated Gunite Pool & Waterview.

4 Bayshore Drive, Shelter Island NY
photos

by () on {PROPERTY_GENERIC_PRICE_REDUCED_DATE_TRUNCATED}

OPEN ,

3 br  /  2 ba  /  2,000 sqft

Single-Family Home

(11964)

The Corcoran Group

Source: corcoran.com corcoran.com

Broker: The Corcoran Group

Agent: Carolyn Stromberg

Listing Type: Rental

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
SHELTER ISLAND MID CENTURY MODERN WATERVIEWLocated at the end of a quiet road, this vintage modern, designed by a French architect,…

$20,000 /mo
67A Menantic Road, Shelter Island NY
photos

by () on {PROPERTY_GENERIC_PRICE_REDUCED_DATE_TRUNCATED}

OPEN ,

3 br  /  2 ba  /  1,500 sqft

Single-Family Home

(11964)

The Corcoran Group

Source: corcoran.com corcoran.com

Broker: The Corcoran Group

Agent: Carolyn Stromberg

Listing Type: Rental

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
GINGERBREAD FARMHOUSECharming farmhouse with rocking chair front porch in very convenient location. 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, living room,…

10 Saint Marys Road, Shelter Island NY
20 photos

by () on {PROPERTY_GENERIC_PRICE_REDUCED_DATE_TRUNCATED}

OPEN ,

3 br  /  2 ba

Single-Family Home

(11964)

Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl R…

Source: danielgale.com danielgale.com

Broker: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl R…

Agent: Linda McCarthy

Listing Type: Rental

Year Built: 1970

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
Newly Renovated, This Adorable Waterfront 3Br/2Ba Cottage With Deepwater Dock Is New To The Rental Market. It Won't Last...

$5,000 /mo
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
5 photos

by () on {PROPERTY_GENERIC_PRICE_REDUCED_DATE_TRUNCATED}

OPEN ,

3 br  /  3 ba  /  2,650 sqft

Single-Family Home

(11964)

1townandcountry.com

Source: 1townandcountry.com 1townandcountry.com

Broker: 1townandcountry.com

Agent: Jeanmarie Bay

Listing Type: Rental

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
dramatic cathedral ceilings, CAC, heated pool, outdoor shower, wireless, broadband& IN. service,DirecTV,3 TIVO units & LCD TV's. The…

Rent vs. Buy Calculator

$ Enter a value greater than 0.
% Enter a value between 0-100%.
$ Enter a value greater than 0.
  Enter a value between 1-30.
Copyright © 2012 Trulia, Inc. All rights reserved.   |   Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity
Updating results...
[x]
,
Showing address and nearby
homes for sale